Meat Snacks Go Mainstream
By Mary Ellen Kuhn
Protein, portability and portion control are helping to keep the category strong with consumers.
Meat snacks just
aren’t what they used to be. And that’s actually a good thing.
Today’s meat snacks are softer, sometimes shaped
differently and available in more exotic flavor and seasoning combinations.
They’re also targeted to a broader base of consumers and positioned
for different eating occasions. (Think lunch boxes.) Factors such as these
are helping to position the category for further growth.
A peek at Chicago-based Infor-mation Resources, Inc.
data suggests that sales are a bit lackluster, but it’s important to
keep in mind that these statistics include neither the all-important
convenience channel nor Wal-Mart — another key retail venue for meat
snacks. For the year-long period ending Nov. 4, 2007, for example, jerky
sales in supermarkets, drug stores and mass merchandisers excluding
Wal-Mart were off by 2.1% for a total of $206.4 million. Sales of all other
dried meat snacks were up just .2% for a total of $107.1 million.
But that doesn’t tell the full story.
According to leading meat snack vendors such as Jack Link’s brand marketer
Link Snacks, Minong, Wis., the convenience channel accounts for nearly 50%
of category sales volume, with Wal-Mart contributing almost 20% more. And
sales in those channels have been strong, at least for Jack Link’s.
With fewer consumers enamored with low-carb dieting
these days, meat snack marketers must work harder to get the word out about
their products’ attributes.
“We’re in a really competitive industry,
especially with beef jerky,” says Baron Bridgford II, special
projects manager for Chicago-based Bridgford Foods. Retailers are cutting
back on the number of vendors whose products they stock, opting to go with
a shorter list of top performers, Bridgford continues, adding that he
believes, ultimately, that this works to benefit the shopper.
“Too much variety can be overwhelming for the
consumer,” Bridgford says.
Top 5 Brands: Jerky | |||||
Latest 52 weeks ending Feb. 24, 2008 | |||||
Rank | Brand | Dollar Sales (in millions) | Dollar Sales % Change vs. Previous Year | Dollar Share | Dollar Share Change vs. Previous Year |
1 | Oh Boy! Oberto | $63.4 | +1.9 | 30.7 | +0.2 |
2 | Jack Link's | $60.1 | +28.2 | 29.0 | +6.1 |
3 | Private label | $27.0 | -3.2 | 13.0 | -0.6 |
4 | Bridgford | $13.6 | -18.4 | 6.6 | -1.6 |
5 | Pemmican | $8.4 | -26.7 | 4.0 | -1.5 |
Total, including brands not shown | $207.3 | +1.1 | 100.0 | ||
Top 5 Brands: Dried Meat Snacks (excluding pork rinds and jerky) | |||||
Latest 52 weeks ending Feb. 24, 2008 | |||||
Rank | Brand | Dollar Sales (in millions) | Dollar Sales % Change vs. Previous Year | Dollar Share | Dollar Share Change vs. Previous Year |
1 | Slim Jim | $47.5 | +1.4 | 44.5 | +0.2 |
2 | Jack Link's | $20.3 | +11.5 | 19.0 | +1.8 |
3 | Old Wisconsin | $15.9 | -4.1 | 14.9 | -0.8 |
4 | Hickory Farms | $4.1 | -29.0 | 3.8 | -1.6 |
5 | Private label | $ 3.1 | +565.2 | 2.9 | +2.4 |
Total, including brands not shown | $106.7 | +1.0 | 100.0 | ||
Source: Information Resources, Inc. (IRI) Total U.S. -- supermarkets, drugstores and mass merchandise outlets (excluding Wal-Mart) |
Keeping it Current
At the same time, however, new product forms —
included in IRI’s “all other” categorization — are
adding excitement to the category. Jack
Link’s X-Bites, for example, are
bite-size pieces of smoked sausage packaged in easily portable, 2-oz.
packages. The company also is introducing meat snacks in multipacks that
are designed to appeal to lunch box-packing moms and brown baggers.
Frito-Lay, Plano, Texas, has moved into the emerging
100-calorie arena, already well-established in other snack categories, with
the rollout of Oh Boy! Oberto 100 Calorie Original Beef Jerky Bites and 100 Calorie Teriyaki
Turkey Jerky Bites. These single-serving products retail for $1.99 and
deliver a portion-control benefit.
In addition, meat snack makers are doing their best to
create products that are moister and easier to chew in order to appeal to
consumers, including children, who traditionally aren’t fans of
jerky’s — dare we say it — tough texture.
“More tender and softer-chewing product is the
wave of the future,” says Hans Evenson, sales and marketing manager
for Old Trapper Smoked Products, Forest Grove, Ore. He attributes Old
Trapper’s ability to achieve sales growth of 20% annually for the
past three years to the fact that it offers a product that’s softer
and moister than conventional meat snacks.
“That’s been our focus all along, but I
think you’ll see the whole industry moving that way,” Evenson
predicts.
An ethnic influence has arrived in the meat snacks
category, as well. For example, Jack
Link’s is adding a new Sweet and
Spicy Thai-flavored jerky. Market tests showed it had a strong appeal to
women, says Bret Ocholik, vice president of marketing and innovation for
the company. Introducing this sort of exotic product provides an
opportunity to generate trial and also offers heavy users more product
choices, Ocholik observes.
ConAgra’s Slim Jim brand has heated things up, too, inviting consumers to
“unleash their spicy side” on an interactive Web site, explains
Ann Mamer Lloyd, vice president of marketing for meat snacks at ConAgra
Foods, Omaha, Neb. The Slim Jim lineup boasts a number of spicy flavor options, including
Tabasco, Chili and a Sweet n’ Spicy varieties.
“Advertising creative showcases what happens
when one’s spicy side gets out,” Lloyd says.
As marketers in myriad food and beverage categories
have done, meat snack companies are introducing an expanded array of
premium offerings.
“Meat snacks as a category appeals to a number
of different consumers, including those looking for a more premium
product,” Lloyd says. “Slim Jim Meat Sticks appeal to a younger audience looking for a
product to prove their coolness, while our jerky items — Pemmican, Slim Jim and Harley Davidson Beef Jerky
— appeal to an older, more premium audience looking for flavor and
quality.”
Silver Creek Specialty Meats, Oshkosh, Wis., hopes to
appeal to consumers who seek a top quality product option with its new line
of meat snack strips that boast distinctive, upscale ingredient blends as
well as an upgraded nutritional profile. The snack strips are made using a
process of slow roasting and light smoking, which yields a tender, moist
product.
“We believe there is a good opportunity to
expand the product portfolio in the meat snacking category,” says
Mike Halverson, sales and marketing manager for the company.
“We’ve developed some new ideas.” So far the
company’s snack strip options include Chicken with Salsa and
Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese, Chicken with Italian Seasonings and Romano
Cheese, and sirloin
with cranberries
and wild
blueberries. A 1-oz. snack strip carries a suggested retail price of
$1.25-$1.50, and a five-pack sells for about $6.99.
Packaging Pluses
Across all segments of the category, retailers are
pressuring vendors to streamline packaging.
“One trend right now seems to be a movement
toward less waste in packaging, resulting in smaller packages that are more
full of product,” observes Bridgford. “I think a lot of people
were wary at first that a smaller package would imply less product to the
consumer, but many retailers are demanding smaller footprints for each SKU.
Wal-Mart and Target are two big driving factors behind this
initiative.”
This move toward packaging sustainability has the
added benefit of delivering more convenience to the consumer.
“It makes our snacks more portable,”
Bridgford says. “Women can carry them in purses; kids can keep them
in their backpacks or lunch pails.”
For Link Snacks, new packaging technology has allowed
the company to up the convenience factor, Ocholik reports. Using
oxygen-absorbing film for its Jack Links
X-Bites’ portable, tube-style
packaging let the company eliminate an oxygen absorber inside the package.
This was important, Ocholik explains, because the notched corner at the top
of the package is designed to enable a consumer to rip it open and pour the
bite-size pieces directly into the mouth or hand. Including an oxygen
absorber would have posed a choking hazard for the on-the-go consumer, he
says.
As product and packaging options expand, so, too, does
the range of consumers to whom the products appeal.
“More and more women seem to be entering the
category and eating meat snacks as part of diets and [including them in]
their children’s lunches and snacks,” Bridgford notes.
Jack Link’s, for
one, is committed to targeting more than the traditional core audience of
young males. The company’s irreverent “Messin’ with
Sasquatch” television advertising campaign of 2007 was well-received.
For 2008, however, the goal is to allow the marketing communications effort
evolve to include more public relations, print and online components, and
to expand its focus beyond “image and fun” to include
nutrition, health and convenience messages, Ocholik says.
The idea, Ocholik explains, is to communicate with
consumers who may not automatically include meat snacks on their mental
lists of potential snacks.
“For people who aren’t considering meat
snacks, we want to get the message out as to why they should consider
them,” he says.
And just what do today’s consumers want?
“Health, convenience and satiety,” Ocholik
summarizes, “and meat snacks sits right on top of all of
those.”
Organic Options
One trend intriguing many meat snack consumers is
organic. Among the manufacturers catering to this niche is Mirab USA, Inc.,
part of the Marfrig Group, based in Taylor, Mich. Mirab’s Farmer’s Market brand
offers Original and Cherry & Apple Wood Smoked varieties of beef
jerkey, as well as its Honey BBQ Apple and Cherry Wood Smoked Beef Tenders,
which are brand-new to the marketplace.
As Mark Stieglitz, senior vice president of business
development for Mirab, notes, “Organic is hot.”
Protein Power
The Atkins Diet peak is past, of course, but the meat
snack category still benefits from consumers who are interested in adding
more lean protein to their diets.
“In general, we make a healthy snack, and we
feel that more and more consumers are being health-conscious when making
their snack purchases,” says Baron Bridgford II, special projects
manager for Bridgford Foods, Chicago. “I think more people are buying
these snacks regularly now as opposed to sporadic impulse purchases.”
Many dieters are seeking foods that will help them
feel full without overdoing fat, calorie and carbohydrate intake. Meat
snacks fit the bill because they are “calorie-dense,” says Bret
Ocholik, vice president of marketing and innovation for Link Snacks,
Minong, Wis. For example, he notes that the company is introducing meat
snacks in multipack, single-serve packs that contain just 50 calories each.
“We give people a decent amount of product for
those 50 calories,” Ocholik observes. “We don’t have to
change our product to deliver that portion-control.”
Marketers at Silver Creek Specialty Meats, Oshkosh,
Wis., have even calculated the Weight Watchers Points value of the
company’s new Sliver Creek meat snack strips. Each 1-oz. strip contains 50
calories and is just half a point in the Weight Watchers food-tallying
methodology.
Silver Creek is developing point-of-purchase materials
that call out the snack sticks’ healthful nutritional profile, says
Mike Halverson, sales and marketing manager for the company. The materials
flag the high-protein, low-fat attributes of the product as well as the
fact that it contains no MSG.
Silver Creek staffer Sue Cramlich says that
health-conscious consumers are a key target audience for the snack sticks.
They are “light, but filling,” she reports, noting that this
makes them an optimal snack for athletes and other active individuals,
which is why outdoor and sporting goods retailers are high on Silver
Creek’s list of targets for the new item.
Tools for Category Growth
Viable options abound for retailing meat snacks, so
figuring out what works best in a particular channel or chain may take a
bit of experimentation. Meat snack vendors offer a wide array of product
and pack types, so one of a retailer’s key challenges is to figure
out which products have the most profit potential. Consider the following
recommendations:
• Run the
numbers on DSD vs. warehouse-shipped. Having meat snacks
direct-store-delivered tends to mean a lower profit margin per item, but it
also makes life simpler at retail and eliminates or reduces the cost of
warehousing and in-the-store set maintenance. Thus, some careful category
analysis is required.
• Don’t
forget the front end. The meat snack category tends to be
better-established on the West Coast, and more retailers there merchandise
it in the front of the store. As the category continues to attract a
broader cross-section of consumers, more retailers may find that it makes
sense to add some SKUs at the front end and capitalize on meat
snacks’ strong margins and high impulse appeal.
• Consider a seasonal
shipper. Consumers love shopping solutions — that is, merchandising
strategies that solve a problem or simply life. Meat snack trays that
include crackers, dipping sauce and cheese supply that benefit and, thus,
can help boost holiday sales. Gift baskets that contain meat snacks, cheese
and more also offer an alternative to candy gifts.